APB Cold Case

APB Cold CaseAPB Cold CaseAPB Cold Case
  • Home
  • Episodes
  • Submit a Case
  • About Us
  • APB Behind The Badge
  • Resources
  • Reviews
  • More
    • Home
    • Episodes
    • Submit a Case
    • About Us
    • APB Behind The Badge
    • Resources
    • Reviews

APB Cold Case

APB Cold CaseAPB Cold CaseAPB Cold Case
  • Home
  • Episodes
  • Submit a Case
  • About Us
  • APB Behind The Badge
  • Resources
  • Reviews

PART 5 - MISSING IN THE KEYS

PART 4 - MISSING IN THE KEYS

PART 3 - MISSING IN THE KEYS

PART 2 - MISSING IN THE KEYS

PART 1 - MISSING IN THE KEYS

Missing in the Keys

The puzzling disappearance of two teenage girls in 1974. We examine their last movements, controversies in the case, and some people known to have been in the area - some with evil intentions.

BLOG

SHOW NOTES - MISSING IN THE KEYS

Who's Who - click to scroll/enlarge

Who's Who - click to scroll/enlarge

Map 1 - click to enlarge

Map 2 - click to enlarge

Map 2 - click to enlarge

Map 3 - Missing in the Keys - click to enlarge

Map 3 - Missing in the Keys - click to enlarge

Timeline - click to scroll/enlarge

Timeline - click to scroll/enlarge

74th Street trailer diagram

Mobile home trailer on 74th Street - click to view

Cindy Gooding

Cindy Gooding

Age-progressed image of Cindy Gooding; National Ctr. for Missing and Exploited Children

Age-progressed image of Cindy Gooding; National Ctr. for Missing and Exploited Children

Age-progressed image of Cindy Gooding; National Ctr. for Missing and Exploited Children

Age-progressed image of Cindy Gooding; National Ctr. for Missing and Exploited Children

Terry Riggs Alfonso - Photo courtesy of family

Terry Riggs Alfonso - Photo courtesy of family

Age-progressed image of Terry Alfonso; National Ctr. for Missing and Exploited Children

Age-progressed image of Terry Alfonso; National Ctr. for Missing and Exploited Children

Age-progressed image of Terry Alfonso; National Ctr. for Missing and Exploited Children

Age-progressed image of Terry Alfonso; National Ctr. for Missing and Exploited Children

Cindy Gooding (left) and siblings in 1970; Photo courtesy of Diane Hedricks

Marathon Movie Theater 1974

Marathon Movie Theater March 22, 1974; Photo: Monroe County Public Libraries

Family of Terry Alfonso at family gathering; Photo courtesy of family

Family of Terry Alfonso at family gathering; Photo courtesy of family

Cindy Gooding in 1970's; Photo courtesy of Diane Hedricks

Cindy Gooding in 1970's; Photo courtesy of Diane Hedricks

Cindy Gooding around 1974 prior to disappearances; Photo courtesy of family

Cindy Gooding and her siblings in 1970; Photo courtesy of Diane Hedricks

Shark fishing in Marathon, 1970's

Shark fishing in Marathon, July 4, 1974; Photo: Monroe County Public Libraries

South side Marathon, FL - 1970-'s

South side Marathon, FL from 108th-109th Streets - circa 1970; Photo: Monroe County Public Libraries

MISSING IN THE KEYS

SHOW CREDITS

Co Producers: Jeanna Spawn; Mark Spawn 

Host: Mark Spawn

Theme Music: Shie Rozow

Logo Design: Kerry Weisbruch

Additional Music and Sound Effects: Pond5

Announcer: Heidi Marty

Associate Producers: Nyla Spawn, Dominick Macherone

Featuring: Darlene Villareal, Diane Hedricks, Kevin Poeling, Bonnie Padron, Patricia Bourcier, Terri Pease Cameron, Cherie McMillen, former Marathon resident Sharon, and others

Special Thanks: Dominick Macherone; Cindy Sorenson, Patti Bourcier, Lt. Paul Bean, Sgt. Barney Sajdak; Family of Cindy Gooding and Terry Alfonso
 

SOURCE MATERIAL; PHOTOGRAPHS

Monroe County Sheriff’s Office

Family of Terry Alfonso

Family of Cindy Gooding

Historic photos of south side Marathon, shark fishing, and Marathon Movie Theater courtesy of Monroe County Public Libraries, Florida Keys History Center, Key West, Florida

National Center for Missing and Exploited Children (age-progressed images) 

PAUL CRON – Multnomah County Sheriff’s office – mugshot

JAMES WALTER STARRETT – Fort Lauderdale News 1971 Apr 04 Page 5 andSummers-Starrett-Shockey-Thomasville-Times-Enterprise-January,13-1971-p-8

ANTHONY LARETTE – Missouri Dept of Corrections

GERARD SCHAEFER – Sheriff’s Office Martin County, FLA(5/18/73 mugshot)

JOSEPH “CRAZY JOE” SPAZIANO - Orange County Sheriff’s Dept, Orlando, FL mugshot

https://www.newspapers.com/article/the-orlando-sentinel/68740349/

CARL ERIC “CHARLIE” BRANDT https://www.fandom.com/licensingand https://skdb.fandom.com/wiki/BRANDT_Carl/Gallery

BOBBY JACK FOWLER – Lincoln County Sheriff’s Office, Newport Oregon mugshot

ROBERT CLARK KEEBLER – Broward Co Sheriff’s Dept webpage

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=18gPtefdGGc

RODNEY ALCALA – By Huntington Beach Police Department - Huntington Beach Police Department, Public Domain, https://commons.wikimedia.org/w/index.php?curid=135043318

CHRISTOPHER WILDER - FBI

GERALD STANO – Daytona Beach Police Dept from Wiki

https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Gerald_Stano_1980_mugshot.png

TED BUNDY – FBI Wanted Poster https://www.fbi.gov/image-repository/bundy-wanted-poster.jpeg


SOURCE MATERIAL; ARTICLES, PUBLISHED REPORTS

Florida Jane Doe IDed after nearly 48 years may be victim of serial killer cop Gerard Schaefer; Crystal Bonvillian, Cox Media Group; 6/3/2022; https://www.kiro7.com/news/trending/florida-jane-doe-identified-after-nearly-48-years-may-be-victim-serial-killer-cop/EVQOSTZJ6VDSFOFMJV7UKLMGWI/ 

Former Deputy Suspected in Deaths of 7; Walton Beach Playground Daily News; 5/15/1973; p. 2

Mother is ready to let go; Chris Doyle; Key West Citizen; 4/29/1992, p. 2

Marathon musicians sing songs to aid missing kids; Key West Citizen; 9/27/1987, p. 6

Note about human bones found in October in Marathon; Monroe County Sheriff’s Office/Florida Keys Sheriff blog; 3/2/2011 

Woman digs up bones in her garden; NBC Miami 10/11/2010; https://www.nbcmiami.com/news/local/woman-digs-up-human-bones-in-her-garden/1842365/ 

Bobby Jack Fowler, suspect in death of Newport teen girls, may have killed 20 or more people; Lori Tobias, The Oregonian; 10/29/2012; https://www.oregonlive.com/pacific-northwest-news/2012/10/bobby_jack_fowler_suspect_in_d.html 

U.S. convict linked to teen’s 1974 death; Altoona Mirror; 9/26/2012, p. 34

Man linked to Canada murder lived on Bolivar in 80s, 90s; Galveston Daily News; 9/26/2012, p.1

Bonaparte man sent to Anamosa; Ottumwa Courier; 11/8/1983, p. 7 

Slaying suspects; Thomasville Times Enterprise; 1/13/1971, p. 8

Rodney Alcala; Santa Ana Orange County Register; 3/31/2010, p. 1

Broward County Sheriff’s Office; Open and Unsolved: The Murders of Barbara Schreiber and Darlene Zetterower; 8/23/2023

Bonaparte man hit with baseball bat; Ottumwa Courier; 8/1/1983, p. 8

Fowler sentenced for arson attempt; Fairfield Ledger; 11/8/1983, p. 10

State’s arson law upheld by Iowa Court of Appeals; Oskaloosa Herald; 12/18/1985, p. 2

Arrested on assault count; Fort Madison Daily Democrat; 8/1/1983, p.2

Oregon DNA lab at 5000 hits; Gazette Times; 2/24/2013, p. 16

Pinellas County detective met with condemned killer to solve murders; Panama City News Herald; 12/24/1995, p. 22

Gerard Schaefer, Plaintiff/Appellant v. Michael Newton and Avon Brooks, Defendants/Appellees; 57 F.3d 1073 (7th Cit. 1995) 

North Plains hostage situation ends; Joany Carlin; The Oregonian; 11/11/2007;  https://www.oregonlive.com/breakingnews/2007/11/north_plains_hostage_crisis_en.html 

Domestic violence standoff in North Plains ends peacefully; Washington County Sheriff’s Office press release, Hillsboro, Oregon; WSCO case 07-520059; 11/11/2007


Connect With Us


Copyright © 2024  The Spawn Group, LLC - All Rights Reserved.

  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms and Conditions
  • Media Inquiries
  • In the Media...

This website uses cookies.

We use cookies to analyze website traffic and optimize your website experience. By accepting our use of cookies, your data will be aggregated with all other user data.

Accept